How to send news tips to azcentral.com and The Arizona Republic
Readers can send tips to The Arizona Republic and azcentral.com via the newspaper’s social media channels or by email at [email protected].
The Republic
Lea la historia en español
The life of Paloma Nicole Arellano, 14, was cut short after undergoing breast implant surgery at a private clinic in Durango, Mexico.
It all began with a deception, the local press said. Carlos Arellano, Paloma’s father, received a call from his ex-partner a day before the tragedy unfolded. The girl’s mother informed him that, after testing positive for COVID-19 at school, the two of them would be traveling to the Durango mountains to isolate themselves at a cabin that didn’t have phone service. Worried but confident, Carlos didn’t suspect the dark reality that hid behind the mother’s lie.
The truth didn’t emerge until Paloma’s funeral. It was during the service that Carlos discovered that his daughter had not died from complications of an illness, but from a cosmetic surgery procedure she had secretly undergone.
On September 12, while her father believed she was staying at the Durango mountains, Paloma underwent breast augmentation surgery. The surgeon was no stranger: it was Víctor “N,” her mother’s current partner, who performed the procedure with her consent but not Carlos’. The surgery, which should’ve been a step toward a supposed cosmetic improvement, triggered a cascade of devastating medical complications.
What followed was a week of agony. The after-effects of the surgery were critical: cardiorespiratory arrest and severe brain swelling that led doctors to induce a coma and connect the 14-year-old to a ventilator. Only then, when the situation was despairing, did the mother decide to contact Carlos to inform him about his daughter’s condition.
“At the funeral, some relatives told me her breasts were larger than what she had before and when I mentioned it to her mother, she told me it wasn’t true, that she didn’t know anything. That night, I asked her mother to leave the room so I could talk to the girl, to say my goodbyes. For some reason, she didn’t want to. I managed to convince her and her entire family to leave, and they did. My sister, my sister-in-law, my mother, and I stayed inside. They examined my daughter, and sure enough: she had breast implants. We have photographs of the implants and the scars. We immediately requested an autopsy,” he said in a statement from the Prosecutor’s Office.
Carlos went to the prosecutor’s office and reported the incident. He pointed to the doctor, Paloma’s mother, the hospital, and everyone else involved in what he calls a “cover-up” as directly responsible for his daughter’s death.
Social Pressure vs. Necessary Treatments
Paloma’s death raises alarming questions about the pressure of beauty standards, driven by social media platforms like Instagram and TikTok, which increasingly affect young teenagers. It also generates conversations about the responsibility of healthcare professionals and parents in ensuring minors’ consent and safety in elective surgeries.
For Claudia Gómez, fashion expert and Director of Estilo de Vida magazine, this case is not just a story of an untimely death, but a classic example of the correlation of social pressure and the rise in cosmetic surgery among adolescents.
“We have cases of girls who, as young as 9, have been talking about having surgery. They live enslaved by beauty, and more than beauty, they focus on ‘what people will say’ on their social media; they stop eating, they go to inappropriate places, it’s all become a madness,” Gómez said.
According to the fashion expert, the problem also lies in the fabricated images that artists, celebrities, and influencers often portray.
“It’s vital now that parents make it clear to their children that what they portray on social media is false ideals; reality is different, and that beauty is not only physical but also mental and spiritual,” she said.
Adolescents between the ages of 13 and 19 are increasingly seeking cosmetic procedures
Until a few years ago, cosmetic surgery procedures were considered an exclusive procedure among older adults. However, experts affirm that plastic surgery has gained popularity among younger patients and has begun to transform the generational landscape.
2024 statistics continue to reflect these trends. The American Society of Plastic Surgeons reports that in 1996, 14,000 cosmetic procedures were performed on teenager patients. The number increased to 286,690 cosmetic procedures on patients between the ages of 13 and 19 by 2024. Of these, 263,342 were minimally invasive and 23,348 were surgical procedures.
“In the case of minors, we have two situations: one where the minors are being deeply affected, that is, the parents say that their children no longer enjoy the activities they once did. That when they have stopped going to dance classes or participating in swimming and other activities they used to enjoy, that is a sign it may be time to consider plastic surgery,” noted Scott Hollenbecks, MD, president of the American Society of Plastic Surgeon.
He cited some cases, such as boys with very large breasts seeking a reduction, or girls with breast asymmetry, meaning one breast is larger than the other, and even cases of girls with very large breasts that prevent them from participating in sports.
“Then there are procedures where someone is basically fine, looks like everyone else, but wants to change their appearance. They’re looking for more of a cosmetic procedure, and most medical professionals would be extremely reluctant to perform surgery in those cases when it comes to young patients or anyone under 18,” he said.
Procedures most requested by young people
Demand is focused on both surgical and noninvasive treatments. The most popular procedures in 2024 included:
- Breast Reduction (cosmetic patients only): 5,325 cases
- Nose reshaping (rhinoplasty): 4,810 cases
- Liposuction: 3,117 cases
- Male breast reduction (gynecomastia surgery): 2,942 cases
- Breast augmentation (implant placement, both for primary and revision surgeries): 2,774 cases
- Ear surgery (otoplasty): 1,706 cases
1 in 6 parents do not approve of surgeries in minors without restrictions
To understand parents’ views on the possibility of their children undergoing plastic surgery, the University of Michigan conducted the National Poll on Children’s Health at the C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital. The report revealed that in the United States, there is a largely cautious attitude despite the social normalization of these practices.
The key finding included:
Limited conditional approval: 1 in 6 parents (approximately 16%) believe that adolescents should be allowed to undergo non-surgical cosmetic procedures for any reason, as long as they have parental permission.
Bullying is not a sufficient reason: 50% of those surveyed firmly stated that being bullied or harassed due to physical appearance “is not a valid reason” for a teenager to turn to these procedures.
Real demand at home: The study quantifies direct interest, indicating that 1 in 14 parents (around 7%) acknowledge that their teenager has inquired about the possibility of undergoing a non-surgical cosmetic procedure.
The decisive impact of social media
But the danger not only lies in the social pressure that teenagers currently experience, it’s also in the growing number of unqualified individuals or doctors who often use social media as a marketing tool to offer services that are dangerous to patients.
“Always look for a certified plastic surgeon. Truly good doctors usually get their patients through referrals from other patients, not just something on social media. Do as much research as you can. If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. This is different from buying a car or a new pair of shoes. It’s your health and your life. Don’t risk it for a $1,000 discount,” Hollenbecks said.
In the case of minors, the doctor advised parents to wait until their kid reaches 18 or 19 years of age.
“Unless the child’s life is negatively and perhaps irreversibly affected—unless they drop out of their activities, don’t want to go to school, or have their grades drop—we will always advise that the later the better.”
Regarding cases in which only one parent seeks cosmetic or surgical treatment for their children, Hollenbecks said that in the United States, the approval of both parents is usually sought before proceeding with any cosmetic surgery.
“As a doctor, you wouldn’t do something knowingly that goes against the will of one of the parents. I suppose you could be deceived by a parent, perhaps. All families experience different situations, but I don’t think any doctor would do something knowing that it would go against a parent’s approval. That would only cause problems for everyone at some point,” he said.
Paloma’s case: a reflection of deception
Paloma fought for her life for seven days straight, but the consequences were irreversible. She died on Saturday, Sept. 20, at the Santa María Clinic in Durango, Mexico, according to Yadira de la Garza Fragoso, Durango Attorney General.
On Sept. 21, the teenager’s father appeared before the Prosecutor’s Office, stating that he wanted to file a complaint and that the teenager be given an autopsy.
“It was a breast surgery, which he and his family had confirmed at the funeral home and request that this be carried out according to the law,” Yadira de la Garza Fragoso, the Attorney General of Durango, said.
According to the claim filed, both parents initially agreed not to request an autopsy and relied on the hospital’s death certificate, which indicated the cause of death was cerebral edema resulting from a respiratory illness.
“We are investigating a probable lack of care on the part of the mother, a criminal offense contemplated in our code, placing a minor who was under her care and custody in risky situations,” the Prosecutor said.
“The doctor is also reviewing whether there was malpractice in the surgery performed on the teenager. There could be a crime of negligent homicide, and probably medical-professional liability,” she said.
Grief into action
Paloma’s story highlights how cosmetic surgery has gone from being a taboo subject to a socially accepted and accessible tool, especially among an increasingly younger population, a fact that parents like Carlos Arellano believe must be monitored.
Following his daughter’s death, he launched an awareness campaign on social media addressing the dangers and social pressure young people face today to achieve a perfect physical image.
Under the slogan “girls don’t need implants,” he has called for a march of parents on September 27.
“We cannot continue to normalize the sexualization of girls or allow the ambition of some adults to put their lives at risk. We demand justice and that this crime does not go unpunished. Girls deserve to grow up free, safe, and respected,” he announced on his Instagram account.
link
More Stories
Median Arcuate Ligament Syndrome | Orlando surgeon explains signs, symptoms and treatment
Gyder Surgical announces first commercial surgical cases in the United States performed by Dr. Paul M. Lombardi, M.D., at the Tri-County Orthopedics’ Joint Replacement Institute outpatient center
Bunion Surgery Market Get Facts About Business Strategies 2026 to 2031: Medi-tech Insights